TBM in state government and higher education: what the cost model has to carry
In brief
How TBM and IT cost recovery work in state agencies and public universities: funds, rates, federated campuses, legislative reporting and what models need.
Steve Elliott · · 8 min read
On this page
TBM works in state government and public universities, but the cost model has to carry facts a corporate model can ignore: which fund paid, which appropriation allowed it, which rate recovered it, and which agencies or campuses never reported at all. Washington State began building a statewide TBM program in 2012 and now requires every agency with at least $250,000 a year in IT spending to categorize that spend in it.
In our view, that changes the design priority. A public-sector TBM model should first explain rates and fund splits to budget offices and legislators, and only then benchmark towers. This post reads the official record: Washington's statute and policy, NASCIO's data on how state CIO offices are funded, the federal rules on central service rates, and EDUCAUSE's benchmarking data. Federal agencies are a separate story, covered in why IT cost transparency projects stall.
Which states use TBM or IT cost recovery?
Of the official sources we found, Washington's is the clearest case of TBM written into law. State law gives WaTech, the state technology agency, the duty to coordinate with agencies whose annual IT spending exceeds $10 million on a TBM program "to identify opportunities for savings and efficiencies in information technology expenditures." Policy 113, adopted January 12, 2023, extends participation to agencies spending $250,000 or more. Those agencies must categorize IT expenditure using the program's taxonomy, submit it no later than 30 calendar days after the Office of Financial Management's (OFM) year-end closing cutoff, and reconcile it at least six months after submission.
WaTech publishes the TBM Taxonomy it uses: TBM Council version 4.0 materials labeled FY2024, including a placemat of cost pools and towers. The state's 2016 NASCIO award nomination dates the start of the program to June 2012, counts 44 agencies in it, puts state technology spending at nearly $1 billion a year, and says the data fed the 2015–17 budget process. A case study the federal CIO Council published in September 2017 reports that "undefined" IT spending fell from 15% to 5% of the total, and that the state adjusted its chart of accounts rather than make wholesale changes to an accounting system more than 40 years old.
Other states publish less about TBM but plenty about cost recovery:
| State | How central IT is funded | Source |
|---|---|---|
| North Carolina | Cost recovery was 49.45% of NCDIT's $804.6 million budgeted revenue in FY2023–24. General fund appropriations were 10.11%. | NCDIT annual report |
| Minnesota | Rate-based chargebacks through the Enterprise Technology Fund, pass-through chargebacks for agency applications and projects, and general fund appropriations for governance and cybersecurity | 2028–29 biennial budget narrative, October 2026 |
| Washington | OFM's central service model spreads funding for WaTech's central services across agencies on bases such as statewide FTEs, agency IT FTEs or agency IT spend | OFM budget instructions, June 2024 |
What do NASCIO's surveys say about state IT funding?
Most state CIO offices bill agencies, and most also get appropriations. In NASCIO's 2023 State CIO Survey of 49 states, 90% of CIO organizations were funded at least partly by chargeback, 63% by general funds and 20% by agency assessments. Only eight states reported getting all their revenue from chargeback. About three-quarters of chargeback states got more than half their funding that way.
The most common answer on the ideal model was a hybrid of chargeback and general funds. One CIO described it as appropriations for services everyone needs and chargeback for optional ones. NASCIO notes such a hybrid would address agencies' most common complaint: "CIO overhead charges are embedded in all the rates for services."
Cost sits near the top of the agenda. NASCIO's 2026 priorities list ranks budget, cost control and fiscal management third, behind AI and cybersecurity. Its description covers budget reduction, federal funding and strategies for savings. Consolidation and optimization ranks ninth.
What makes public-sector IT cost different?
- Appropriations and fund accounting. Every cost sits in a fund and an appropriation, not just a cost center. Washington's accounting policy separates governmental funds from proprietary funds, and defines internal service funds as those that account for goods or services one agency provides to others on a cost-reimbursement basis. OFM's budget instructions have each agency apply its own fund split to its central service allocation. A single WaTech charge can therefore land in several funds, each with its own appropriation.
- Central rates and working capital. Rates charged to federal awards must recover cost, not earn margin, and be trued up. The federal Uniform Guidance (2 CFR 200, Appendix V) requires each state to submit a central service cost allocation plan to the Department of Health and Human Services every year it claims those costs on federal awards. Billed services must be compared to allowable costs at least annually, with the difference refunded, credited or worked into future rates. A working capital reserve of up to 60 calendar days of cash expenses is considered reasonable. For any recipient of federal awards, universities included, 2 CFR 200.468 names computing facilities among specialized service facilities, whose rates must aim to recover only aggregate costs and be adjusted at least every two years for over- or under-recovery. These are rules about federal awards; confirm how they apply to you with your finance office and advisers.
- Federated agencies and campuses. Large parts of the spend may sit outside the central office or the report. Georgia's FY2025 annual IT report states that it does not cover the legislative or judicial branches, statewide constitutional officers or the University System of Georgia. In higher education, EDUCAUSE's survey treats distributed IT, meaning IT staff and resources outside the top IT officer's purview, as a separate category. In 2015, an EDUCAUSE working group, in partnership with NACUBO, found "data on distributed IT expenditures remain elusive."
- Legislative reporting. Statute sets what is reported, to whom and when. Georgia's report exists because state law (O.C.G.A. 50-25-7.10) requires it. Washington's OFM can ask WaTech to evaluate agency IT budget requests and recommend whether to fund them, under RCW 43.105.240. A budget proviso has Washington's Department of Enterprise Services report every IT contract to the governor and fiscal committees by October 31. The 2025 report collected data from 135 of the 145 required agencies and $1.1 billion in FY2025 contract spending.
- Procurement rules. Contract vehicles may be mandated and centrally held. The same report states: "State agencies are required to use statewide contracts." Early estimates in the report put savings from pooled software brokering at 20% to 40% per license on certain products. In NASCIO's 2025 survey of 51 state and territory CIOs, 74% selected "CIO office owns or manages vendor cloud service contracts" and 72% said their office approves all agency cloud acquisitions.
How does higher education benchmark IT spending?
In our view, higher education has something state governments mostly do without: a shared spending benchmark, the EDUCAUSE Core Data Service (CDS). Its public 2024 almanac, updated February 2024, puts median central IT spending at $10.6 million in FY2022–23, with the middle half of institutions between $4.8 million and $25.3 million. Median central IT spending per student FTE was $1,601, up from $1,500 the year before. Those figures come from 320 to 400 reporting US institutions and are now more than three years old; EDUCAUSE has published later almanacs for members only.
The 2025 CDS survey asks for central IT spending by category, distributed IT spending and budgets, AI spending, and central IT spending across eight service categories. In 2020, before Taxonomy 5.0, EDUCAUSE published a crosswalk from its higher education IT service catalog to the TBM taxonomy, so institutions can compare service areas on a common basis.
Budgets are tightening here too. In an EDUCAUSE QuickPoll in March 2025, 42% of 121 respondents expected IT budget cuts for 2025–26, with a median expected cut of 8%. About 22% had already consolidated distributed and central IT to cut costs, and another 16% were planning to.
In our view, CDS is strongest on central IT, and the distributed share is where a campus TBM model earns its keep. That is the spend no central rate recovers and benchmarks capture least reliably.
What does a TBM model need to do in these settings?
This is our view, built on the sources above.
- Carry fund and appropriation on every cost. Towers and services answer "what is it for." Budget offices also ask "whose money is it." Washington adjusted its chart of accounts rather than overhaul its accounting system. The point is that fund and appropriation travel with the cost through the model, not in a side spreadsheet.
- Treat the rate as a product. Each published rate should trace from cost pools to service to rate, with overhead shown as its own line. That answers the complaint NASCIO reports, and it makes the annual or biennial true-up a model output rather than a reconciliation project.
- Keep cost model and funding model separate. Most states already run hybrids. The same service taxonomy should show which services are appropriated centrally and which are billed, so moving a service between the two is a decision, not a rebuild.
- Report coverage before totals. State plainly which agencies, branches or campuses are in the model and which are not. Georgia's exclusions and the DES contract report's 135 of 145 agencies are honest denominators. A total without one misleads.
- Run on the budget calendar. Washington ties TBM submission to the fiscal year-end close, and OFM adjusts central service funding only in certain budget cycles. A model that refreshes after rates are set explains the past.
- Plan the taxonomy move. Washington's published materials, like the EDUCAUSE crosswalk, predate version 5.0. The TBM Council's version 5.0 made cloud services a standalone cost pool and renamed the Business layer the Consumer layer, among other changes. For a statewide program, that means re-mapping agencies on a schedule the legislature can follow.
Cost, funding source and the decision it informs belong in one operating model, so a legislator's question about a rate can be answered from the same record the CIO used to set it.
Sources
- Revised Code of Washington, RCW 43.105.054, Information technology governance: powers and duties of agency, as amended through 2024
- Revised Code of Washington, RCW 43.105.240, Evaluation of agency information technology spending and budget requests, as amended through 2024
- Washington OCIO, Policy 113: Technology Business Management, adopted January 12, 2023
- WaTech, TBM Taxonomy and FY2024 TBM Taxonomy v4.0 placemat
- Washington Technology Solutions, Technology Business Management (TBM), NASCIO award nomination, 2016
- Federal CIO Council, Technology Business Management Case Study: Washington State, linked from TBM Washington State, September 25, 2017
- Washington OFM, 2025–27 Budget Instructions, Chapter 11: Central Services, June 2024
- Washington OFM, State Administrative and Accounting Manual 80.20
- Washington Department of Enterprise Services, 2025 IT Contracts Legislative Report, October 2025
- NC Department of Information Technology, 2023–2024 Annual Report
- Minnesota Management and Budget, MN.IT Services, 2028–29 Biennial Budget, October 2026
- Georgia Technology Authority, Georgia Annual IT Report, FY 2025
- NASCIO, The 2023 State CIO Survey, 2023
- NASCIO, The 2025 State CIO Survey, 2025
- NASCIO, State CIO Top Ten Policy and Technology Priorities for 2026
- 2 CFR Part 200, Appendix V: State/Local Governmentwide Central Service Cost Allocation Plans
- 2 CFR 200.468, Specialized service facilities
- EDUCAUSE, 2024 CDS Interactive Almanac: IT Spending and Staffing, updated February 2024
- EDUCAUSE, 2026 Core Data Service Almanac: IT Spending and Staffing, July 13, 2026 (members only)
- EDUCAUSE, 2025 IT Organization, Staffing, and Financing survey, 2025
- EDUCAUSE, Technology Business Management and the IT Service Catalog: A Higher Education Crosswalk, 2020
- EDUCAUSE Working Group, in partnership with NACUBO, Calculating the Costs of Distributed IT Staff and Applications, 2015
- Mark McCormack, EDUCAUSE, EDUCAUSE QuickPoll Results: Technology Budgets and Staffing, April 2025
- TBM Council, Update Your TBM Model with a New Taxonomy Version, July 16, 2025
Frequently asked questions
Do state governments use TBM?
Some do. Washington is the clearest case we found: state law directs WaTech to coordinate a TBM program with agencies spending over $10 million a year on IT, and Policy 113 extends it to agencies spending $250,000 or more. Other states, such as North Carolina and Minnesota, publish IT cost recovery and rate data, though the documents we read do not call it TBM.
How do state CIO offices recover IT costs?
Mostly through a mix of chargeback and appropriations. In NASCIO's 2023 survey, 90% of state CIO organizations used chargeback and 63% used general funds, and only eight relied entirely on chargeback. Rates for central services claimed on federal awards must be compared with allowable costs at least annually, with differences refunded, credited or carried into future rates.
What does the EDUCAUSE Core Data Service measure?
CDS collects central IT spending, staffing and services data from colleges and universities each year, plus distributed IT spending outside the central IT unit. Its public 2024 almanac reported median central IT spending of $10.6 million and $1,601 per student FTE in FY2022–23, based on 320 to 400 US institutions.
How is TBM in a public university different from a company?
A public university works in funds and appropriations, recovers central IT costs through rates that, where charged to federal awards, must be cost-based and periodically trued up, and can have IT spending in schools and departments outside central IT, which EDUCAUSE tracks separately as distributed IT. In our view, the model must carry fund source, rate logic and coverage, not just towers and services.
Steve Elliott
Published November 22, 2026
More on TBM & IT Financial Management
Cost pools, towers, showback, unit cost.
Keep reading
What the 2025 State of TBM report shows, and what it can't
The 2025 State of TBM finds high-maturity orgs 2–3x more likely to report significant impact. A close read and how to cite it in a business case.
TBM in health systems: technology cost on margins this thin
About 43% of hospitals in Kaufman Hall's sample run at a loss. How TBM helps health systems cost the EHR, defend cyber spend and price IT into service lines.
TBM, ITFM or FP&A: who should own IT cost?
ITFM is the function, TBM the method, FP&A the enterprise planning team. How their remits differ, where they collide, and our view on who should own IT cost.
TBM after an acquisition: how to merge two IT cost models
After a deal, two IT cost models rarely add up. Map both to one TBM taxonomy, conform capitalization, and baseline run cost per tower before synergy targets.