TBM in health systems: technology cost on margins this thin
In brief
About 43% of hospitals in Kaufman Hall's sample run at a loss. How TBM helps health systems cost the EHR, defend cyber spend and price IT into service lines.
Steve Elliott · · 8 min read
On this page
- Why is technology cost hard to see in a health system?
- How much of the IT budget is the EHR?
- Should clinical and administrative technology be costed the same way?
- What did the Change Healthcare attack show about vendor and cyber risk?
- How does the Medicare cost report interact with a TBM model?
- What does this look like in numbers?
- Where should a health system start?
- Sources
In a health system, technology cost transparency is a margin question first. Kaufman Hall's National Hospital Flash Report for August 2026 put year-to-date operating margins at 2.5% including allocations, with roughly 43% of hospitals in its sample operating at a loss, so a few million dollars of technology cost can decide whether a hospital breaks even.
What's different from other industries is where the cost hides. Much of it sits in one clinical system, a large share depends on outside vendors, and the Medicare cost report has its own rules for how overhead moves. In our view, a TBM model earns its keep in health care when it shows what the EHR really costs and who uses it. It should also show how much security spending the margin can carry.
Why is technology cost hard to see in a health system?
Hospital finance hides it in several ways.
- It arrives as overhead. CMS's cost report instructions describe general service costs as expenses of operating the facility as a whole, with examples that include administrative salaries, utilities and "computer hardware and software costs." Those costs are then stepped down to patient care cost centers.
- Much of the system cost arrives as one amount. Under CMS's Home Office Cost Statement instructions, a health system's home office assigns costs directly where it can, allocates others on a statistical basis, and pools the rest. Each hospital records directly assigned costs in the matching account. Capital costs go to its capital cost centers. The rest of the non-capital share goes into administrative and general (A&G) as one amount under a heading such as home office costs.
- Benchmarks split on allocations. Kaufman Hall, which draws on more than 1,300 hospitals, reports a hospital margin with and without allocations. Its methodology note lists corporate functions such as IT, HR and administration among the shared-service costs a system allocates to its hospitals.
In our view, the result is that a hospital CFO often sees technology as part of an A&G allocation rather than as named services with owners. That works for cost reporting, not for deciding whether an ambulatory expansion or a new security program is affordable.
How much of the IT budget is the EHR?
We could not find a verified, current public figure for the EHR's share of a typical hospital IT budget. In our view, most figures that circulate come from surveys whose method isn't published. You should measure your own, and the answer depends heavily on what you count.
The clearest public evidence on that point comes from the Department of Veterans Affairs. In its March 2025 report, GAO said VA's 2019 life cycle estimate for its new EHR was $16.1 billion: a contract worth up to nearly $10 billion over 10 years, plus $6.1 billion for infrastructure readiness and program management. An independent estimate by the Institute for Defense Analyses in 2022 put the total at $49.8 billion, including 15 years of sustainment.
VA's program is not typical, but it shows the pattern a total cost of ownership view is meant to catch: the vendor contract was under two-thirds of even the original estimate.
Should clinical and administrative technology be costed the same way?
The cost report's instructions list computer hardware and software among general service costs, with no split between clinical and administrative use. We think a management cost model should make that split.
Clinical technology, such as the EHR's clinical modules, imaging systems and connected medical devices, is consumed in proportion to patient activity: encounters, orders, studies, beds. Administrative technology, such as ERP, payroll and most of revenue cycle, scales more with staff and transactions. Allocating both on one basis, such as revenue, hides the difference.
TBM Taxonomy 5.0 gives more room for this than earlier versions. It added a Smart Devices tower, with Industrial & Control Systems and Intelligent Devices sub-towers. In our view, that tower could house networked clinical equipment, though clinical engineering may own those budgets. Version 5.0 also renamed the Business layer the Consumer layer and added products, value streams and digital services, which, we think, lets a health system name service lines and facilities as consumers rather than cost centers.
What did the Change Healthcare attack show about vendor and cyber risk?
It showed how much hospital cash flow depends on vendors that sit outside the IT budget.
- In a survey of nearly 1,000 hospitals published March 15, 2024, the American Hospital Association found that 94% reported a financial impact from the attack, 83% an impact on cash flow and 74% a direct impact on patient care.
- UnitedHealth Group reported $3.09 billion in total 2024 cyberattack impacts, made up of $867 million in business disruption and $2.22 billion in direct response costs. Separately, it lent care providers $9.03 billion in 2024 in connection with the attack.
- Change Healthcare told HHS's Office for Civil Rights (OCR) in July 2025 that about 192.7 million individuals were affected.
OCR's report to Congress for 2024 counted 663 breaches affecting 500 or more people. Hacking and IT incidents were 81% of those reports. Business associates filed 16% of the reports but accounted for 85% of the individuals affected.
Regulation may add cost. HHS proposed a rewrite of the HIPAA Security Rule in December 2024. It would require a technology asset inventory, a network map of how electronic protected health information moves, and annual written verification from business associates of their technical safeguards. HHS estimated the rule's first-year costs at about $9 billion. The rule is still a proposal: law firms tracking OCR's regulatory agenda reported in July 2026 that final action is now projected for July 2027, after an earlier May 2026 target. Confirm your obligations with counsel before you budget for it.
How does the Medicare cost report interact with a TBM model?
They answer different questions, and in our view they should reconcile rather than compete.
The cost report uses the step-down method: once a general service cost center's costs are allocated, it is closed. A TBM model typically flows cost from cost pools to IT towers to solutions to consumers, using consumption drivers. That's fine for management reporting, as long as the TBM model ties back to the general ledger and to the same cost center totals that feed the cost report.
Two practical points follow. First, if the TBM model shows that IT cost is consumed very differently from how it's reported, that's a finding for your reimbursement team, not a reason to change the cost report on your own. Second, we think the home office allocation steps CMS describes (direct, functional, pooled) resemble TBM's direct and driver-based allocation, so the same shared services data can often feed both. Confirm any change to cost reporting with your reimbursement advisers and auditors.
What does this look like in numbers?
Take an illustrative health system with $2.5 billion in operating revenue and a 1.5% operating margin, or $37.5 million. These figures are made up for the example.
Its annual EHR cost, built up the TBM way, might look like this:
| Cost element | Main TBM mapping (pool / tower) | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| Vendor subscription and maintenance | Software & SaaS / Application | $14.0M |
| Hosting | Cloud Services or Outside Services: Managed Services / Compute | $6.0M |
| Internal analysts, builders and trainers | Staffing / Application | $16.0M |
| Interfaces and integration engine | Software & SaaS / Application: Middleware | $3.0M |
| Share of clinical end-user devices | Hardware / End User | $4.0M |
| Share of security operations | Staffing / Security | $2.0M |
| EHR total | EHR solution | $45.0M |
The vendor line is 31% of the total. A renewal that looks only at the $14 million misses most of the money.
Now allocate the $45 million to consumers two ways:
| Consumer | Share of revenue | Share of encounters | Allocated by revenue | Allocated by encounters |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flagship hospital | 60% | 40% | $27.0M | $18.0M |
| Community hospitals | 30% | 25% | $13.5M | $11.25M |
| Ambulatory clinics | 10% | 35% | $4.5M | $15.75M |
On an encounter basis, the ambulatory clinics carry $15.75 million, 3.5 times their $4.5 million revenue-based share. A Kaufman Hall managing director said in its February 2026 release that outpatient demand is rising, so we think the driver choice matters more each year: a system shifting volume to clinics needs to know what each visit costs to support.
The same model frames the cyber case. A $5 million a year increase in security spending equals 13% of this system's operating margin. With Security as its own tower, separate from Risk & Compliance in Taxonomy 5.0, the board can see what that $5 million protects: which solutions, which vendors with access to patient data, and which service lines would stop if they went down.
Where should a health system start?
Start from a decision with a date, as we argue in why IT cost transparency projects stall.
- Pick the next EHR decision. A renewal, an instance consolidation or an acquisition onto your EHR gives the model a deadline and an owner.
- Build EHR total cost first. Count every line in the table above, not just the contract.
- Name service lines and facilities as consumers. Use encounters, orders or clinician log-ins as drivers, and show the revenue-based result beside them.
- Tag every vendor that touches patient data or claims. Record which solutions and consumers depend on each one. If the Security Rule is finalized as proposed, it would require a technology asset inventory and a network map, and this work would feed both.
- Reconcile to the general ledger and the cost report totals. Keep management drivers and reimbursement statistics separate but traceable.
On margins this thin, technology cost belongs in the same operating model as the service-line plan and the capital decision, so the cost of the EHR and the case for security spending sit next to the choices they affect.
Sources
- Kaufman Hall, National Hospital Flash Report: August 2026 Data, October 13, 2026
- Kaufman Hall, National Hospital Flash Report Methodology Update (undated)
- Kaufman Hall, Hospitals Face the 2026 "New Normal": Rising Expenses and Shifts in Revenue Mix, February 10, 2026
- CMS, Provider Reimbursement Manual, Part 2, Chapter 40, Form CMS-2552-10 instructions, §4000 and §4013 (text of Rev. 10 as hosted by NBER)
- CMS, Provider Reimbursement Manual, Part 2, Chapter 48: Home Office Cost Statement, Form CMS-287-22, §4800.12–4800.13, Transmittal 1, October 2022
- GAO, Electronic Health Records: VA Making Incremental Improvements in New System but Needs Updated Cost Estimate and Schedule (GAO-25-106874), March 12, 2025
- American Hospital Association, AHA Survey: Change Healthcare Cyberattack Significantly Disrupts Patient Care, Hospitals' Finances, March 15, 2024
- UnitedHealth Group, 2024 results, Form 8-K Exhibit 99.1, January 16, 2025
- HHS Office for Civil Rights, Change Healthcare Cybersecurity Incident Frequently Asked Questions, last reviewed August 13, 2025
- HHS Office for Civil Rights, Annual Report to Congress on Breaches of Unsecured Protected Health Information, calendar year 2024
- HHS Office for Civil Rights, HIPAA Security Rule NPRM fact sheet, December 27, 2024
- Federal Register, HIPAA Security Rule To Strengthen the Cybersecurity of Electronic Protected Health Information (proposed rule), January 6, 2025
- Holland & Knight, HIPAA Security Rule Amendments Now Projected for July 2027, July 6, 2026
- Alston & Bird, HHS Delays HIPAA Security Rule to 2027, July 10, 2026
- TBM Council, TBM Taxonomy, current tower and cost pool tables
- TBM Council, Update Your TBM Model with a New Taxonomy Version, July 16, 2025
Frequently asked questions
How is TBM different in a hospital or health system?
The method is the same, but the pressures differ. Margins are thin, so small technology costs move results. Much of the spend sits in the EHR and with outside vendors. And the Medicare cost report lists computer hardware and software among general service costs that are stepped down to patient care, so the TBM model has to reconcile to it.
What belongs in EHR total cost of ownership?
Beyond the vendor subscription or license and maintenance, count hosting, internal analysts, builders and trainers, interfaces, the share of clinical end-user devices, and a share of security operations. GAO's review of VA's EHR program shows the gap: VA's 2019 estimate added $6.1 billion of infrastructure and program management to a contract worth up to nearly $10 billion.
Can TBM allocations be used on the Medicare cost report?
Not automatically. The cost report follows CMS's step-down method and its own statistical bases, while TBM models use management drivers chosen for decisions. Keep the two traceable to the same general ledger and cost center totals, and treat any difference as a finding for your reimbursement team. Confirm any change to cost reporting with your reimbursement advisers and auditors.
How should a hospital frame a cybersecurity investment for its board?
State the cost as a share of operating margin, then show what it protects: named solutions, vendors with access to patient data, and the service lines that depend on them. Public evidence helps set the stakes. OCR's 2024 breach report found business associates filed 16% of large breach reports but accounted for 85% of individuals affected.
Steve Elliott
Published November 22, 2026
More on TBM & IT Financial Management
Cost pools, towers, showback, unit cost.
Keep reading
Cost center or product P&L: where technology cost should land
Should technology run as a cost center, a shared-services recharge or inside product P&Ls? What each model does to behavior, plus a worked margin example.
TBM, ITFM or FP&A: who should own IT cost?
ITFM is the function, TBM the method, FP&A the enterprise planning team. How their remits differ, where they collide, and our view on who should own IT cost.
TBM after an acquisition: how to merge two IT cost models
After a deal, two IT cost models rarely add up. Map both to one TBM taxonomy, conform capitalization, and baseline run cost per tower before synergy targets.
TBM in state government and higher education: what the cost model has to carry
How TBM and IT cost recovery work in state agencies and public universities: funds, rates, federated campuses, legislative reporting and what models need.